Stocks, Bonds, Bills, and Inflation

Stocks, Bonds, Bills, and Inflation was a long-running U.S. capital-market data series and annual yearbook used to compare historical asset-class returns.

Stocks, Bonds, Bills, and Inflation (SBBI) refers to a long-running U.S. capital-market dataset and publication series associated with Roger Ibbotson and Rex Sinquefield. It compiled historical returns for major stock and fixed-income categories alongside inflation, with core series extending back to 1926. The annual SBBI Yearbook is now discontinued, so an analyst using it must identify the edition, its ending date, and any separate source used to update the history.

SBBI is historical evidence, not a forecast and not an investable portfolio. Its value comes from consistent long-horizon comparisons and detailed series definitions.

Key Takeaways

  • SBBI compared U.S. asset-class total returns with inflation over long periods.
  • The publication passed through Ibbotson Associates, Morningstar, and Duff & Phelps/Kroll before annual editions ended after 2023.
  • “Stocks,” “bonds,” and “bills” are constructed benchmark series, not every security in each category.
  • Nominal returns must be compounded with inflation, not merely reduced by it, to calculate exact real returns.
  • Historical averages depend on the sample period, arithmetic versus geometric averaging, reinvestment assumptions, and series methodology.
  • A discontinued dataset should not be extended by joining new data without documenting the replacement source and splice method.

What SBBI Contained

The full yearbooks included returns, index values, and statistical analysis for several U.S. capital-market series. Coverage varied by edition, but commonly included:

Historical seriesBroad exposure representedQuestion to verify
Large-company stocksU.S. large-cap equity total returnsWhich stock index and reinvestment convention?
Small-company stocksA small-cap or micro-cap equity seriesDid the proxy or construction change over time?
Long-term corporate bondsLong-maturity corporate fixed incomeWhich credit-quality and maturity rules?
Long-term government bondsLong-duration U.S. government securitiesWas a constant-maturity or one-bond portfolio used?
Intermediate government bondsMedium-maturity U.S. government securitiesHow was the replacement security selected?
Treasury billsShort-term U.S. government billsWhich maturity and reinvestment rule?
InflationU.S. consumer-price changeWhich CPI series and timing convention?

The labels are convenient summaries. They do not make unlike asset classes equally liquid, equally risky, or directly investable under the same costs and taxes.

Publication History and Current Status

Ibbotson and Sinquefield’s 1976 research assembled year-by-year U.S. returns beginning in 1926. Ibbotson Associates later developed the material into the familiar SBBI publication and data products.

The publication lineage then changed:

PeriodPublisher or stewardPractical implication
Before 2007Ibbotson AssociatesEarly editions and series definitions must be read in their historical context
2007-2015MorningstarEditions may use Morningstar branding and licensed SBBI data
2016-2023Duff & Phelps, later KrollThe yearbook remained a historical U.S. capital-market reference
After 2023No new annual SBBI YearbookCurrent analysis requires clearly identified replacement data

The absence of a new yearbook does not invalidate the historical observations. It does mean that phrases such as “the latest SBBI return” are no longer self-explanatory.

Nominal and Real Return

SBBI comparisons often distinguish nominal return from growth in purchasing power. The exact real return is:

$$ r_{\text{real}} = \frac{1+r_{\text{nominal}}}{1+\pi}-1 $$

where (\pi) is the inflation rate over the same period.

Worked Example

Suppose a stock benchmark earns a 10% nominal total return while inflation is 4%:

$$ r_{\text{real}} = \frac{1.10}{1.04}-1 =5.77\% $$

Simply subtracting 4% from 10% gives 6%, which is a close approximation at modest rates but not the exact compounded result. Taxes, investment fees, and trading costs would reduce an investor’s realized outcome further and are separate from the benchmark calculation.

Arithmetic vs. Geometric Average

Historical return discussions can produce different “average” returns from the same observations.

AverageCalculationBest answers
Arithmetic meanAdd periodic returns and divide by the number of periodsWhat was the average one-period observation?
Geometric meanCompound the returns and solve for the constant growth rateWhat constant annual rate links beginning and ending wealth?

If an investment rises 50% and then falls 50%, its arithmetic average return is 0%:

$$ \frac{50\%+(-50\%)}{2}=0\% $$

But $100 becomes $150 and then $75. The two-period geometric return is:

$$ \left(\frac{75}{100}\right)^{1/2}-1\approx-13.4\%\text{ per year} $$

Quoting “the historical average” without naming the averaging method can therefore be materially misleading.

What SBBI Can Help Analyze

Long-run asset-class behavior

The history can show that higher long-run returns came with substantial year-to-year variation and severe drawdowns. It provides context for risk, but it does not prove that the same ranking will hold over a particular future horizon.

Inflation and purchasing power

Comparing nominal asset returns with inflation shows whether a benchmark increased real purchasing power. The inflation series still may not match an individual household’s spending pattern.

Risk-premium research

Analysts have used SBBI data to estimate historical differences between stocks and government securities. A historical premium is sensitive to the start date, end date, averaging method, selected risk-free proxy, and whether the analysis uses income or total returns. It is not automatically a forward-looking expected return.

Education and scenario design

The data can illustrate compounding, volatility, recovery periods, and the difference between nominal and real wealth. Those lessons remain useful even when the publication itself is no longer updated.

How to Use an Older Edition

  1. Record the exact yearbook edition and data cutoff.
  2. Read the definition of every asset-class series used.
  3. Confirm whether returns include income and reinvestment.
  4. Match nominal returns with inflation over identical dates.
  5. State whether averages are arithmetic or geometric.
  6. Check for methodology or proxy changes within the historical series.
  7. If adding recent years, document the new provider, index, splice date, and any break in comparability.
  8. Preserve the original data rather than silently overwriting it with reconstructed values.

Risks and Limitations

  • Past-performance risk: A long sample does not guarantee future returns or eliminate regime changes.
  • U.S. concentration: The classic history does not represent every global market or investor currency.
  • Proxy risk: A constructed asset-class series can differ from securities available to an investor at the time.
  • Methodology changes: Definitions, sources, and calculations can change across editions.
  • Survivorship and availability: Historical series require careful treatment of securities that disappeared and data not known at the time.
  • Cost omission: Index returns commonly omit management fees, advice fees, taxes, and implementation costs.
  • Inflation mismatch: Consumer-price inflation does not equal every investor’s personal cost change.
  • Discontinuation: Combining SBBI with a successor series can create an undocumented structural break.

Sources

FAQs

Is the SBBI Yearbook still published annually?

No. The 2023 yearbook was the final annual edition. Historical material remains useful, but current-period extensions need a separately identified data source and methodology.

Does SBBI show what investors will earn in the future?

No. It documents historical benchmark returns. Future returns can differ because valuations, yields, inflation, market structure, taxes, and economic conditions change.

Can SBBI returns be treated as investable returns?

Not automatically. The series use defined benchmark assumptions and may omit fees, taxes, transaction costs, and implementation constraints. Review the series methodology before comparing it with a real portfolio.

This page is educational and does not provide personalized investment, valuation, tax, or retirement advice.

Browse Investing