Permanent Mortgage Buydown

A permanent mortgage buydown uses upfront discount points to obtain a lower note rate for the loan term, subject to the lender's pricing and loan terms.

A permanent mortgage buydown uses upfront funds, usually paid as discount points at closing, to obtain a lower contractual interest rate than the lender would otherwise offer for the same loan. Unlike a temporary buydown, the lower rate is written into the note and applies for the loan term unless the mortgage is paid off, refinanced, or modified.

The word “permanent” distinguishes the pricing choice from a short payment subsidy. It does not mean the borrower must keep the mortgage forever or that the quoted rate reduction is guaranteed to produce savings.

Key Takeaways

  • A permanent buydown changes the mortgage’s note rate; a temporary buydown generally does not.
  • One discount point equals 1% of the loan amount, but one point does not produce a fixed or universal rate reduction.
  • The upfront cost should be compared with expected monthly savings and the time the borrower expects to keep the loan.
  • Selling, refinancing, or paying off the mortgage before the break-even date can reduce or eliminate the expected benefit.
  • Points, lender credits, fees, annual percentage rate, and loan terms should be compared on the same date and for the same scenario.

How a Permanent Buydown Works

Mortgage lenders typically offer a range of rate-and-cost combinations. One option may have fewer upfront points and a higher rate. Another may require more points and provide a lower rate. The borrower chooses among the available combinations before closing, and the selected note rate determines scheduled interest and principal-and-interest payments.

A discount point is calculated as:

$$ \text{Point Cost} = \text{Loan Amount} \times \text{Points Percentage} $$

For a $400,000 mortgage, one point costs:

$$ \$400{,}000 \times 1\% = \$4{,}000 $$

The rate reduction purchased by that point depends on market conditions, loan type, term, occupancy, credit profile, lock period, and lender pricing. It should be taken from an actual quote or Loan Estimate, not assumed from a rule of thumb.

Worked Example

Assume a borrower compares two 30-year fixed-rate offers on a $400,000 mortgage:

ChoiceNote ratePoints paidMonthly principal and interest
No-point illustration6.50%$0$2,528.27
Permanent buydown illustration6.25%$4,000$2,462.87

The lower-rate option reduces scheduled principal and interest by about $65.40 per month. A simple break-even estimate is:

$$ \text{Break-Even Months} = \frac{\$4{,}000}{\$65.40} \approx 61.2 $$

Under this simplified comparison, the points are recovered after roughly 62 monthly payments. The example excludes differences in other fees, tax treatment, opportunity cost, mortgage insurance, and the time value of money. Actual quotes may also require more or less than one point for a 0.25 percentage-point rate difference.

Permanent vs. Temporary Buydown

FeaturePermanent buydownTemporary buydown
Note rateLower contractual rateUsually unchanged
Payment effectLower scheduled principal and interest for the termLower borrower-funded amount during a defined opening period
FundingDiscount points paid at closingFunds deposited for scheduled payment subsidies
QualificationBased on applicable underwriting termsAgency programs generally require qualification at the note rate
Main riskPaying upfront and exiting before break-evenPayment increase when subsidy ends and full-payment obligation

The documents matter more than the marketing label. A borrower should identify the note rate, points, credits, temporary subsidy agreement, and payment schedule separately.

How to Evaluate a Permanent Buydown

Compare matched quotes

Compare offers for the same property, loan amount, term, loan type, occupancy, down payment, lock period, and date. A rate from one scenario cannot be compared reliably with points from another.

Estimate the holding period

Break-even analysis depends on how long the mortgage remains outstanding. Consider a possible sale, refinance, relocation, prepayment, or other event that could end the loan before the points are recovered.

Review cash at closing

Paying points uses cash that could otherwise support the down payment, closing costs, repairs, or emergency reserves. A lower payment is not necessarily valuable if the upfront charge weakens liquidity.

Compare APR and total loan costs

The annual percentage rate can help compare financing costs, but it relies on assumptions and is not a substitute for reviewing the Loan Estimate. Check the points, lender credits, origination charges, cash to close, projected payments, and five-year comparison.

Identify who pays

The borrower, seller, builder, lender, or another permitted party may fund points, subject to loan-program and contribution limits. A seller-funded buydown is not free in an economic sense if it affects the negotiated home price or replaces another concession.

Why Lender Credits Are the Reverse Tradeoff

Discount Points generally exchange more upfront cost for a lower rate. Lender credits generally exchange a higher rate for help with eligible closing costs. Neither direction is automatically superior. The better fit depends on the borrower’s cash constraints, expected holding period, and actual pricing.

Risks and Limitations

  • Short holding period: Points may not be recovered before the loan ends.
  • Opportunity cost: Upfront cash could have been held as reserves, used to reduce principal, or used elsewhere.
  • Rate uncertainty: Future refinancing opportunities are unknown; a later lower-rate refinance could shorten the benefit period.
  • Pricing opacity: Advertised rates may assume points, borrower characteristics, or transaction details that do not match the actual loan.
  • Contribution limits: Seller, builder, lender, and other interested-party payments may be limited or treated differently by program rules.
  • Tax uncertainty: The treatment of points depends on jurisdiction and facts. Educational examples should not be treated as tax advice.

Common Mistakes

  • Assuming that one point always lowers the rate by the same amount.
  • Calling a temporary payment subsidy a permanent rate reduction.
  • Dividing point cost by payment savings without considering other fee differences.
  • Comparing a quoted rate with points to another rate without points.
  • Treating the break-even month as a guarantee rather than a scenario estimate.
  • Spending reserves solely to obtain a lower payment without testing the remaining cash buffer.

Authoritative Sources

Mortgage pricing and program rules vary by lender, loan type, jurisdiction, and date. This material is educational and is not individualized mortgage, legal, tax, or financial advice.

  • Mortgage Buydown: General comparison of permanent and temporary buydown structures.
  • Temporary Mortgage Buydown: Funded reduction in the borrower’s opening payments without changing the note rate.
  • Fixed-Rate Mortgage: Mortgage with an unchanged note rate for the contractual term.
  • Mortgage Points: Upfront charges expressed as a percentage of the loan amount.
  • Refinancing: Replacement financing that can end the original break-even period.

FAQs

Does one mortgage point always reduce the rate by 0.25 percentage points?

No. One point always equals 1% of the loan amount, but the associated rate reduction depends on the lender’s current pricing and the loan scenario.

Can a seller pay for a permanent buydown?

It may be permitted, but seller and other interested-party contributions are subject to the applicable loan program, underwriting limits, contract terms, and disclosure requirements.

Is a permanent buydown refundable after refinancing or sale?

Generally, points purchase the selected rate at closing rather than creating a refundable balance. The controlling documents determine the treatment of any charge.

How should borrowers compare a buydown with a larger down payment?

Compare cash to close, monthly payment, mortgage insurance, interest, liquidity, and the expected holding period under each documented scenario. The result is borrower-specific.
Browse Mortgages and Real Estate Finance